BJ lives/Maxie dies 2/24 episode

Ok, I know I am a sap but I was in tears a few times today. I was surprised they showed Maxie's year of birth on the tombstone. 1990. That makes her 19 this year. I really thought they had aged her a bit. I did not remember that BJ was 4 yrs older than her...it's been so long since all that happened.

Good eye Kathy! I missed the date. I thought Maxie was older at her transplant. There were a couple things that made me sad but mostly seeing Bobby & Monica in Patty's office. I miss them together :( But I really MISS Bobbie it's been so long since she has been on.

It was sad seeing Robin & Mac like that!

One thing I noticed is when Lulu was talking about Maxie, wouldn't she have been a baby when Maxie was in the hospital. Hmmm.... I guess I will have to look that up.

I think it's really funny that Patrick & Carly are always together in the dreams.

The Wicked One wrote:I thought this episode was pretty silly to be honest.

ITA it was one of those hours

I liked it and I cried a lot. What I don't get is how Maxie dying had an affect on John being a jerk.

I also didn't care for BJ hooker wig.

As usual the continuity wasn't there.


First...BJ was born in 1986...so yes techinically she was four years older than Maxie who was born on Halloween 1990. BUT when they brought Robyn Richards in to play Maxie they slightly aged her...SO it made Maxie and BJ pretty much the same age...give a year...I believe that again the writers think we're stupid and dont' notice things like that....esp since when Georgie died wasn't she like 19....and Maxie being the older sis would have been about 21 then...therefore I think Maxie is now about 22/23 years old.

Lulu wasn't born till AUGUST of 1994...ergo she was not born yet when Maxie had her heart transplant. She wouldn't know anything that happened back then...and even though they've aged the girl TWICE since JMB began playing her...she's still younger than Maxie.

Re: this ep...I wasn't entertained actually. there were TOO MANY holes in the plot...too many folks missing from the canvas that SHOULD have been there.

I agree with you on that ISIS. Too many loopholes.

I did enjoy seeming Mac and Robin. Too bad there was no mention of Georgie. I can't believe Carly turned out the way she did, a childless tramp.

ISIS wrote:As usual the continuity wasn't there.


First...BJ was born in 1986...so yes techinically she was four years older than Maxie who was born on Halloween 1990. BUT when they brought Robyn Richards in to play Maxie they slightly aged her...SO it made Maxie and BJ pretty much the same age...give a year...I believe that again the writers think we're stupid and dont' notice things like that....esp since when Georgie died wasn't she like 19....and Maxie being the older sis would have been about 21 then...therefore I think Maxie is now about 22/23 years old.

Lulu wasn't born till AUGUST of 1994...ergo she was not born yet when Maxie had her heart transplant. She wouldn't know anything that happened back then...and even though they've aged the girl TWICE since JMB began playing her...she's still younger than Maxie.

Re: this ep...I wasn't entertained actually. there were TOO MANY holes in the plot...too many folks missing from the canvas that SHOULD have been there.

I'm glad you wrote this Isis, I thought Lulu hadn't been born yet as the SPencers had came in 93 & Laura wasn't prego at the time. Also I thought Maxie was older at the time. I thought I was remembering wrong again LOL


The part I hated the most was Bobbie getting her walking papers (it feels like a bit of foreshadowing). I also think Bobbie should have been featured at the end at BJ's grave.

The Wicked One wrote:Guza shouldn't try an episode about the past when he doesn't even know the shows history.

ITA

I did enjoy the episode, but I'm glad it was only one. I like anything that focuses on Maxie, but it was a little over the top and cheesy.

It was cheesy.

KMonacoRocks wrote:I did enjoy the episode, but I'm glad it was only one. I like anything that focuses on Maxie, but it was a little over the top and cheesy.

It was WAY over the top and very cheesy.

Jenny,

Maxie was having a dream about what life would be like if BJ lived and she died.

samizgh wrote:Jenny,

Maxie was having a dream about what life would be like if BJ lived and she died.

Yup she did and none of it made sense. lol

It was a change of pace for me. I like little things like that every now and then. And it was not about the mob either. I like that too.

IA Kathy I like the change of pace every once in awhile.

It was over the top but nice to see people in a different light.